Three big issues for women – Your thoughts on an austere diet, men’s problems, and the news on hormone therapy.

Hi friends~

I’m getting this out late today, but holy moly so much is happening, and I wanted to hit a few things all at once. I’d love to get your feedback.

Thoughts on the Washington Post’s article interviewing food scientist Marian Nestle’s daily diet.

Nutrition expert Marian Nestle, 89, just published her most recent book What To Eat Now”. I get it. She’s been writing on food science for decades. She’s aligned with Pollan: “Eat food, not too much, mostly plants”. She was asked what she eats in an interview by The Washington Post to share her daily diet. She sure doesn’t eat very much in caloric quantity, citing a general drop in metabolism with age –  which isn’t necessarily true. This Mayo Clinic article states that resistance training could slow and, in many cases, reverse the changes in muscle fibers associated with aging. This is even true in people who don’t start resistance training until after age 70. And it’s never too late to start.

Marian doesn’t mention any physical activity, but without resistance training and no mention of protein in her diet, she might already have osteoporosis, possibly setting herself up for a catastrophic fracture. 

She says she doesn’t eat breakfast until late in the morning (which could seem like advice from an expert woman recommending intermittent fasting – beware of intermittent fasting). Her diet is austere – she likes plain shredded wheat for example, and loves salads for lunch and dinner, and sometimes cheese and crackers (yes to cheese!). She’ll have an occasional restaurant dinner at a place that serves lovely salads and pasta. And ice cream is her favorite treat. (I’m on with that!) BUT – where’s the protein?

She’s managed to hang around to 89, sharp and functioning well – but she’s a nutrition authority, and this interview seems like advice for longevity – and it’s concerning because some women might follow it. Her regimen risks nutritional and exercise consequences, and I would warn my daughters, granddaughters, and clients against it.

Women have always been attracted to trendy diets, and especially now with GLP1 drugs (intended for people who have diabetes, or are obese), causing decreased appetite, too few calories (including macros), and loss of muscle – leading to osteopenia, osteoporosis, frailty, and fractures.
What are your thought on Marian’s diet?  Would your activity level be sustained with her diet? 
Polli strong with kettlebells
Eat food – protein, carbs, and fat. Be strong for the duration.

The NYTimes published an opinion piece implying that women are responsible for mens’ problems.

Ross Douthat’s opinion piece “ruffled feminist feathers” in his conversation with conservative women, “Did Women Ruin The Workplace? Subtitled, “Can Conservative Feminism Fix it?” Then after backlash, he re-titled the article: “Have Feminine Vices Taken Over The Workplace?” And then tried a third re-title: “Did Liberal Feminism Ruin the Workplace? And if so, can conservative feminism fix it?”

Reactions flooded in to say that the conversation was a desperate attempt to build readership and listeners for his platform, while alienating half of his potential followers. Here’s The Wrap: The New York Times Ridiculed for ‘Did Women Ruin the Workplace?’ Op-Ed: ‘Are You Kidding Me?’

Jessica Valenti wrote in her response:  “It shouldn’t surprise anyone that the same week Douthat and his guests questioned whether American institutions are being destroyed by women’s presence in the workplace, ultra-conservative religious leaders renewed their call to eliminate women’s right to vote.”And, “Times podcast guest Helen Andrews insists women’s presence in public institutions has been a “pathology,” and that “feminization” will destroy the rule of law, one of our repeal-the-19th freaks declares, “emotions cannot be used to rule and govern a nation.”

I hope you’ll read the Times interview transcript, or listen to the interview.
Are strong women a threat?
You bet we are.
Are you’re sensing something ominous … like making birth control illegal, or the repeal of the 19th Amendment? 

And finally the news today (again in the NYTimes)

The black box has been removed from HRT prescriptions. F.D.A. Will Remove Black Box Warnings From Hormone Treatments for Menopause.
A long time coming. The Women’s Health Initiative of 2002 squashed the use of hormone therapy for peri and menopausal women resulting in the drastic reduction of use of hormone therapy. Gradually the science has been evolving.
And now this. The dizzying swing to recommending that HT or HRT, or MHT or whatever it’s called now, as if it will be the lifesaving med for women in menopause, and might even save marriages! The message is that menopause is an affliction to be cured, even that symptoms of menopause might cause divorce. It’s the usual methodology of drug companies to make bucks from sales of a medication, but this crosses a line. Dr. Jen Gunter breaks it down on her Substack, The Vagenda.
Dr. Stacy Sims writes: Understanding the Role of Menopause Hormone Therapy and High-Intensity Exercise in Women’s Cognitive Health and Dr. Jen Gunter’s instagram makes the point that now the government and industry emphasis is on the (unproven) benefits of long-term use of HT, which are still unclear, because the studies have been of limited duration.
Lauding the health benefits of hormone therapy, plus implying that menopause is life threatening or dangerous = you guessed it. Industry profits. So of course the removal of the “black box” warning from hormone therapy products for menopause by the FDA is expected to increase profitability for pharmaceutical companies, and will expand an already growing market monetizing menopause.
I am all for hormone therapy for alleviating vasomotor and other debilitating symptoms of perimenopause and beyond. I was prescribed years ago and it works for me.
Be aware, be informed, and ask a doctor you trust.
What are your thoughts on hormone therapy, this administration’s handling of women’s’ healthcare, or women being pawns in another industry ploy?
I’d really, truly love to hear from you.
We’re all in this together.
xo
Polli

 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share:

More Posts

Little moments, big thanks.

Hi Friends, Last night we capped off a fun-filled week of Thanksgiving travel getting together at home with the local kiddos. It’s always such a

Little girls, parenting, and YOU

Oh my goodness. Friends, there is SO much every day. Tween girls. Read this from one of my favorites, Caitlin Murray’s Soul Snacks, Little Girls